Withings ScanWatch vs Withings ScanWatch 2

The Verdict

Both Withings watches excel at health monitoring with ECG and SpO2 tracking, but the ScanWatch 2 refines the formula meaningfully. The original ScanWatch impresses with its 30-day battery life and hybrid analog display that feels genuinely timeless. However, the ScanWatch 2 improves considerably in key areas: it weighs just 39g versus 58g, making it noticeably more comfortable for all-day wear. The newer model adds skin temperature monitoring, a feature absent from the original that proves valuable for detecting illness early. Both maintain the signature hybrid analog design with digital capabilities, though the ScanWatch 2 upgrades from PMOLED to OLED for slightly crisper visuals. Battery life remains identical at 30 days, cementing Withings' strength here. Neither offers GPS, which limits workout tracking without a paired phone. At $50 more, the ScanWatch 2 delivers tangible upgrades: lighter build, additional health metric, and improved display technology. If you prioritize maximum comfort and comprehensive health data, spend the extra $50 for the ScanWatch 2. However, the original ScanWatch remains an excellent choice if budget matters and skin temperature tracking seems unnecessary for your needs.